Sludge Monster

three generic mana one blue mana Creature — HorrorPower and toughness5/5

Whenever this creature enters or attacks, put a slime counter on up to one other target creature.

Non-Horror creatures with slime counters on them lose all abilities and have base power and toughness 2/2.

Tracking it isn't the hard part.

Showing Innistrad: Midnight Hunt#76

Price

0.44 $

Foil 0.85 $

31 printings · up to 1.46 $

Daily estimate from Scryfall, not a shop quote.

2021-09-24
If a non-Horror creature with a slime counter on it somehow becomes a Horror, the effect making it 2/2 and making it lose its abilities ends. Its base power and toughness will revert to whatever it was before that effect started applying, although other effects that modify power and/or toughness, such as ones created by Auras, counters, and the like may still apply. It'll also have whatever abilities it had before it lost them.
2021-09-24
Sludge Monster's last ability affects all non-Horror creatures with slime counters on them, not just creatures that had slime counters put on them with Sludge Monster's first ability.